The Return of the Big Lie: Anti-Semitism is Winning

Here’s my most recent conversation with my friend Rabbi Joseph.

We discussed Dara Horn’s article in The Atlantic, “The Return of the Big Lie: Anti-Semitism is Winning.”

Show Notes

The conversation explores the rise of antisemitism among the most educated people in America, as discussed in Dara Horn's article. It delves into the shift in liberal values and the toxic political environment that has contributed to the demonization of Jews. The distinction between criticism of Israel and antisemitism is examined, along with the persistence of anti-Semitic myths and conspiracy theories. The need for dialogue, reflection, and reconstitution of relationships is emphasized, as well as the importance of recognizing the value of Jewish survival. The failure of diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives in combating antisemitism is discussed, as well as the fear and challenges faced by Jewish students. The conversation concludes with a call for institutions to engage in meaningful conversation and reflection to address the current climate of hatred.

Takeaways

• The most educated people in America are falling for antisemitic lies, highlighting the need for dialogue and reflection.

• Criticism of Israel is not inherently antisemitic, but the demonization and dehumanization of Jews is a cause for concern.

• Institutions, including universities, need to address the rise of antisemitism and create an environment conducive to living together.

• The toxic political environment and the spread of conspiracy theories contribute to the persistence of antisemitism.

• There is a need for a return to a time when Jews didn't have to constantly prove their right to exist and institutions were safe spaces for Jewish students.